Another Year – Mike Leigh’s latest film: Is it a Duck or a Rabbit?

Another Year - Jim Broadbent, Ruth Sheen & Oliver Maltman

I can’t decide. Is Mike Leigh‘s latest film a duck or a rabbit?

An odd question, I admit, but please bear with me.

I’ve watched a score of his films over the years and I still can’t make up my mind about him.

Is he a filmmaker who produces insightful and compassionate depictions of human nature, or the creator of ghastly, patronising caricatures? I can’t decide.

It’s not that I swing between these two polar views from one film to the next. I hold them simultaneously while I’m watching one of his films. I feel as though I’m looking at one of those old-fashioned optical illusions. One moment I see the duck; the next the rabbit.

I had this experience again with Leigh’s latest film, Another Year. I even watched it twice. You can’t say I don’t try.

It’s another bittersweet study of modern life and stars Jim Broadbent and Ruth Sheen as a late-middle-aged, middle-class couple living in suburban London. Tom is a geologist and Gerri is an NHS counsellor. (Tom and Gerri! Mike, you are a card.)

At ease with their lot, Tom and Gerri serve as emotional life rafts to a couple of their less fortunate friends – Mary (Lesley Manville), a work colleague of Gerri’s, and Ken (Peter Wight), a boyhood friend of Tom’s. Equally lonely and unhappy, self-deluding Mary and self-loathing Ken ooze desperation from every pore. And as the story rolls through the four seasons, punctuated by Tom and Gerri’s regular trips to their beloved allotment, their happiness only gives a keener edge to their friends’ misery.

Another Year - Peter Wight & Lesley Manville

We’ve seen types akin to Mary and Ken before in Leigh’s work, but Tom and Gerri are something of a rarity for the director: a sympathetically drawn middle-class couple – albeit a pair whose backgrounds are salt-of-the-earth working class. A more typical example of Leigh’s treatment of middle-class characters would be the cartoonish yuppie couple in High Hopes, Rupert and Laetitia Boothe-Brain, or the evil landlord in Naked.

Leigh generally doesn’t get flak, however, for his handling of the middle-class; he’s more likely to get stick for his working-class characters. Some even accuse him of offering up a voyeuristic spectacle of lower-class lives for the delectation of middle-class cinemagoers. I don’t buy into that, but I do feel that Leigh’s working methods encourage his actors to tip over into caricature.

Ah, the famous Mike Leigh Method. You know, I’m sure, how Leigh develops his films. Slowly, painstakingly, with characters and scripts emerging out of months of one-to-one research and improvisation with his cast.

Another Year - Oliver Maltman, Lesley Manville & Ruth Sheen

Actors clearly love Leigh’s method, returning to work with him again and again. Broadbent, Sheen, Manville and Wight are all Leigh veterans. And I’m sure they and Leigh will tell you that this creative process gives their characters a hinterland, makes them three-dimensional. Why is it, then, that they so often look to me like exaggerated caricatures?

Manville could probably tell you where Mary went to school, where her parents took her on holiday, the names of her childhood pets (or lack of them). What we see on screen is but the tip of the iceberg. So why then does she need to get a cheap laugh (and, yes, the audience does guffaw) by having Mary pause on the doorstep of Tom and Gerri’s home to adjust her knickers? Yes, I glimpse Mary’s hinterland in Manville’s performance, but I also see the self-indulgent mannerisms.

What do I know? The latest Oscar buzz has Manville tipped for an award and Another Year is supposedly a shoo-in for a Best Picture nomination. Yet I know viewers who found both performance and film so unbearable they left the cinema.

Some see only a rabbit, others only a duck. As for me, I can’t help seeing both.

On general release from 5th November.

If you can see this, then you might need a Flash Player upgrade or you need to install Flash Player if it's missing. Get Flash Player from Adobe.

To activate the sound in the trailer: hold your cursor over the screen to reveal the control panel and click on the volume control in the bottom right-hand corner.
This entry was posted in Cinema Releases, Reviews, The Best View and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Another Year – Mike Leigh’s latest film: Is it a Duck or a Rabbit?

  1. Finnola says:

    Sometimes it’s a swallow, sometimes it’s a sparrow. It soars then it annoys, then soars again. It depends who is viewing and who is relating. I agree the characters can be ‘like exaggerated caricatures?’ I felt creativity, which was was sacrificed for ‘Reality’. (I hope the next generation never have to use this word again.)
    The script seemed to forget that it is film and the audience has suspended disbelief and wants a touch of ‘unreality’ even if it looks real!
    However, mainly it’s a swallow who has flown in amongst the rubbish of America dross to gives us a summer of a film.

  2. Minurka says:

    I saw the film on a mild evening in Barcelona, there were a few middle aged couples and a few groups of middle aged women at the cinema. I left thinking that even in England where the weather invites people to spend more time at home, life cannot be so boring for all the parties involved and singles surely are not so desperate for company as it shows in the film. Truly exaggerated I thought it all was.

  3. matt says:

    The film is actually a veiled critique of the married couple Ken and Gerri whose empathy for Mary does not extend beyond their own peaceful, sedentary, and insulated lives. Most critics have overlooked this. A key metaphor in the film is the garden patch that Ken and Gerri attend to. I am reminded of Voltaire’s “…but, let us cultivate our own garden.” Or to put it another way “Thank god I am me!”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>